Have a tendency to whenever times are given, he is provided which have a day of your own few days one to do perhaps not suits with this big date because it from inside the real history. One analogy occurs in Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner away from Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney refers to sixteen October as the Tuesday, even if 16 October 1993 are a tuesday.
There are also contradictions in guides of this type. Like, for the Harry Potter additionally the Cup from Flame, both step one Sep and 2 September are supplied given that Mondays and, for the Harry Potter plus the Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined to your 20 April, but careful parsing of your own text demonstrates this may has actually took place no later on than March.
In addition to, into the Harry Potter plus the Goblet off Flames they state that the Winners was indeed picked into the Friday 29 October, but 30 October try a saturday when you look at the 1994.
Inside chapter 7 away from Quidditch From the Years, they do say that first Quidditch Business Mug happened in the 1473. In the event the championship is stored all the number of years, that it disputes for the report in Goblet away from Flame your 1994 Industry Mug is actually brand new 422nd. If Quidditch From the Age is good, brand new 422nd Quidditch World Cup manage in fact fall in the season 3161, in case Goblet of Flame is useful, the initial Globe Cup was stored inside 306.
Historic trouble [ ]
Whilst series, with respect to the schedule produced from the new Chamber out-of Secrets site, is decided about 1990s, the series sexy Hohhot girl tend to appears like it’s place in the fresh new late 1990s so you can middle-2000s, more or less concurrent on publication of the books. Inside the Harry Potter plus the Half-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to mention into “predecessor” of the Prime Minister of Uk. With respect to the above schedule, this will take place in the summertime away from 1996, if the Best Minister is actually John Big, whose instantaneous predecessor was a lady (is why earliest interviewing Fudge, the ebook says the fresh election, however, Major was not 1st opted and just took more immediately after Thatcher retired.
You will be able, although not unlikely, that Fudge will be speaing frankly about a far more distant ancestor, since the Thatcher got work environment in advance of Fudge supposedly became Minister to possess Wonders. (No matter if one could envision a scenario where Fudge are delegated by the Minister for Wonders to meet up to your Best Minister as he, Fudge, was at a smaller sized work environment.) As well, the brand new identity and reputation of the top Minister illustrated appears to even more directly fits that Tony Blair than simply from John Significant. A post regarding Each day Mail notes one to Rowling was personal with the upcoming-Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brownish (tend to seen as a competition so you’re able to Blair’s leadership of your own Work People, exactly who been successful him and became Prime Minister), and this she has been wanting to reveal Blair’s poor front side. In case the books was indeed place in connect with book go out of Philosopher’s Brick, up coming that it enjoy create take place in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned into Best Minister).
However, it was afterwards stated that 22 November is actually a friday, it was at 1994
A comparable condition pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply mentioned to be 665 during the latest earliest book, however, Nicolas Flamel try a real historic profile and you can would not have reached you to definitely many years until 1996, in the date the first book was published. The newest rebuttal for it is the fact that go out the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world will not talk to the latest Nicolas Flamel off Harry Potter.
Another type of problem exists regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s period as the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s intended in the series one to Hagrid received one to position contained in this many years from his expulsion away from university in the 1942. However in that scene of Harry Potter and Goblet off Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces regarding the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper frequently overlap having Molly’s decades at school, it seems impractical one she remembers a past gamekeeper. But not, it will be possible that Hagrid don’t feel a good gamekeeper instantaneously just after getting expelled, but rather started due to the fact Ogg’s secretary. This is certainly probable due to the fact whenever Harry believes that he usually feel expelled to own flying into broomstick instead of consent in the first year, he magic in the event the he’d be allowed to stick to just like the Hagrid’s assistant.